Volunteer Profile: Jim Caruso

Jim and Chita Rivera at 2007’s Chita at Birdland event
Photo credit: Steve Sorokoff
By Andy Smith
Host-with-the-most Jim Caruso never needs motivation to raise money for Broadway Cares, because he vividly remembers the early days of the AIDS Epidemic, when losing a friend was an almost weekly occurrence.
For over 15 years, the producer, writer, actor, emcee, and always-in-demand cabaret headliner has used all these skills to raise money for BC/EFA, and for more than a decade, Jim’s been the man with the microphone on the third Sunday in September, emceeing the Celebrity Table at BC/EFA’s Annual Flea Market and Grand Auction.
Last year, Jim’s Broadway at Birdland series presented “Chita Loves Broadway Cares,” one of the most talked-about events of BC/EFA’s season.
My First Time…
“The first event I produced for BC/EFA was in 1991, right after I’d moved to New York from Dallas,” he says. “I’d performed in lots of benefits but I was very intimidated to produce, because it was ‘New York’ and I thought you had to do something extraordinary. My friend Joely Fisher was playing Rizzo in Grease. She was coming to the end of her run and wanted to do a benefit for Broadway Cares and call it ‘Joely’s Last Jam.”’
“She asked me to help because she said ‘I knew people,” Jim remembers. “So we did it, raised a lot of money and I got over my nerves.”
These days, Caruso’s seldom anxious meeting celebrities for the first time at The Flea Market. “Maybe because it’s Sunday morning, it’s a casual atmosphere, and they’re in jeans,” he says, adding that he does get keyed up before encountering people he idolized during his childhood.
“It’s always thrilling to meet your heros! I loved ‘Captain Kangaroo’ as a kid, so meeting Bob Keeshan when I was producing segments for TV was an out-of-body experience. Red Skelton, too,” he says, ticking off iconic names. “Oh, and Betsy Palmer did the celeb table at the Flea Market. I grew up watching her on ‘What’s My Line?’ You just don’t think you’re gonna run into her.”
Steel Town Boy
To paraphrase Auntie Mame (with Jim’s approval), “when you come from Pittsburgh, you have to do something.” The glamorous globe trotter actually did spend his formative years in Western Pennsylvania, moving to Texas with his family at age 18.
“Then I lived in Dallas for 15 years, which was when the AIDS epidemic really hit. Everybody I knew was disappearing.” That’s when the performer became politicized and committed to the cause. “I had always performed at fundraising events, but, let’s face it, when you’re in your twenties doing a benefit for The Heart Association, there’s a sense of detachment, and also a bit of self-aggrandizement if you’re singing,” he says. “But when AIDS hit, everything changed. All of a sudden I was singing for my friends.”

Meeting the President in 1993.
Caruso’s trio Wiseguys performed at the first state dinner of the Clinton administration
Photo credit: White House File
Big Moments
In a varied, highly impressive career, Caruso has dazzled cabaret crowds at The Algonquin’s Oak Room, Carnegie Hall and the Connaught Room in London; guest-hosted "Broadway On Broadway 2000" in Times Square for a crowd of 100,000 fans, and co-hosted five Drama Desk Award webcasts. He's produced for television, covering the Tony Awards and Celebrity Profiles for E! Entertainment. As a writer he’s even covered a dinner at Star Jones’ house for InStyle Magazine.
Another big moment arrived in 1993, when Jim’s vocal trio, Wiseguys, performed at the White House. “Phyllis Newman called me. She was putting together a ‘Broadway Goes to Washington’ show for President Clinton’s inaugural and we ended up performing on the mall on the day of the inaugural.”
Wiseguys’ run of luck continued.
“So, apparently they liked us, because then Phyllis called again and said, ‘Can you do the first State Dinner at the White House?’” In an all-star evening hosted by Lauren Bacall, Wiseguys and their prominent BC/EFA red ribbons caught the attention of Texas Governor Ann Richards. “She put her hand on my heart, over the ribbon, and with tears in her eyes, said, ‘Thank you for that.’”
“It was one of the most extraordinary moments of my life.”
Currently, Jim is touring “the planet,” singing and dancing with his friend Liza Minnelli. “Its real show business, just like I’d dreamed about. We play the most beautiful theaters in the world, and are having a ball. To be onstage with someone as iconic as Liza is the ultimate energy boost,” Caruso says.
“And the crowds go ballistic. It’s like being onstage with Elvis. But better.”
Surreal Life
How many people can claim to be on close terms with both Liza and Tammy Faye Bakker Messner? Caruso worked with the legendary Christian broadcaster in 1996, during her second incarnation as host of a syndicated secular talk show “The Jim J. and Tammy Faye Show.”
“Wiseguys had just broken up and in a moment of high drama I decided to leave show business,” Caruso laughs. “Almost immediately, a friend in LA called up and offered me a job. He said, ‘I don’t know exactly what I’m offering you and I can’t pay you very much.’ Those often-heard words were music to my ears.”
Jim said “yes” to the offer, moved to Los Angeles, rented a purple car, and took a job with no title.
After hitting it off with Jim J. Bullock, Caruso was introduced to Tammy Faye, dressed for the day in a leopard jumpsuit, leopard accessories and leopard go-go boots. “When I complemented her, Tammy Faye said, ‘Leopard is my favorite color!”’
“She was the Real Thing—a crazy concoction, either insanely creative or creatively insane,” says Caruso, who developed a deep fondness and appreciation for the performer, who died in 2007. He offers one more anecdote:
“Once I walked into Tammy Faye’s dressing room and she was putting on a puppet show…for herself.”
Mondays with Jim
The veteran BC/EFA volunteer is probably best known as the host of “Jim Caruso’s Cast Party,” an open-MIC, cabaret variety show held Mondays at Birdland for the past five years.
Backed by Tedd Firth or Billy Stritch on piano and Steve Doyle on bass, each week features an unexpected mix of headliners and talented amateurs eager to try out new material. “Cast Party and the subsequent Broadway at Birdland concert series changed my life. I spent years being extremely self-promotional and nobody gave a s---,” he laughs. “But the second I focused the spotlight on other talent, there was a lot more interest in me and my projects. Why didn’t somebody tell me about that a few decades ago?”
Caruso emphasizes that Cast Party is an all-access show. “What’s interesting is the wide spectrum of age and talent it draws. We’ve seen an 85-year old tap dancer, and the 12-year old girl who won ‘America’s Got Talent,’” he says.
“Betty Comden made one of her last public appearances singing at Cast Party,” Caruso says. “Liza, Michael Feinstein, Tony Bennett and Bon Jovi have all graced us with appearances and performances.”
“We’ve seen superstars and tone-deaf hopefuls, and I’m proud that it draws a diverse crowd and that the audience eats it up and cheers wildly for every single performer,” Caruso says, adding “I think its that joy – the faces of people who love to entertain – that keeps me invigorated and proud to be working in the community.”
[VOLUNTEER SPOTLIGHT ARCHIVE] |